Are you ever fooled by relief inversion?

July 12th, 2011 by Michon Scott
Share

Satellite sensors provide an unprecedented perspective on our planet. Some zoom in for spectacular detail, while others takeĀ the wide view. But while our eyes in the sky give us encyclopedias full of information, they can give us something else: optical illusions.

Many of us have an unconscious expectation to see objects illuminated from above. When looking at paintings or photographs, this means we often expect the light source to occur somewhere off the top edge of the picture. In satellite images, however, this is not always the case.

Earth Observatory generally follows the convention of orienting satellite images so that north is up. For images of the Southern Hemisphere, this rarely presents a problem. But for images of the Northern Hemisphere, sunlight usually comes from the south. Where sunlight illuminates south-facing slopes and leaves northern slopes in shadow, many viewers experience an optical illusion known as relief inversion.

One example of relief inversion comes from the southwestern United States, in the Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument. When north is up, an elaborate network of canyons in the national monument appear, to some viewers at least, to rise above the surrounding land.

When the image is rotated, the canyons look like canyons.

Relief inversion is also pronounced in images of mountainous areas, such as the Bhutan Himalaya.

As before, rotating the image 180 degrees alleviates the optical illusion and makes it easier to identify glaciers flowing downhill and terminating in the glacial lakes.

Perhaps the biggest hazard of relief inversion is that it’s possible to be misled without even realizing it. This is especially true when looking at images of unfamiliar landscapes that few of us encounter in person. The Arabian Peninsula’s Empty Quarter, known as Rub’al Khali, is a huge expanse of shifting sand dunes. When north is up, the salt flats between the dunes appear elevated.

When the image is rotated, this alien landscape is easier to interpret.

A simple solution to relief inversion is to view satellite images from multiple angles — such as printing a copy and turning the page upside down, or using a photo editing software program to rotate the image. If a landscape looks puzzling, try looking from a different angle.

For more information, read “Perceptual biases in the interpretation of 3D shape from shading,” or “Getting real: Reflecting on the new look of National Park Service maps” (PDF).

6 Responses to “Are you ever fooled by relief inversion?”

  1. David Boyle says:

    None of the photos submitted caused me any problems at intrepreting “up.” What do, and to a maddening degree, are planetary photos of craters. In many, many instances, I am unable to trick my head into seeing that the bottom of the crater is down, and not up. Rotating an image can sometimes help, and you can sometimes catch the point where your brain ‘flips’ up and down. Any others, the sun angle is such that no level of photo manipulation lets you see the scene properly. I’m hoping this is strictly a 2-D phenomenon, and that pilots, here or there, never have such problems…

  2. Kurt Wx says:

    I agree with David Boyle’s comment about extraterrestrial landscapes. Although the Algerian false-color image struck me as being inverted, it’s obvious that the ancient arroyos are not ridges. Images of Mars, however, are vexing because it is not always immediately clear where the illumination is from. The high resolution Mars images would be well served if the direction of sunlight were explicitly noted.

  3. Joe Lockett says:

    It’s funny to see comments like this. I used to think I was the only one who occassionaly saw craters as “bumps.” I have found that this phenomenon is particularly evident in grayscale or B&W photos.

  4. Jonathan Hughes says:

    As a child I remember looking at Apollo 8 mission pictures of the moon and suffering from precisely this effect given the sharp shadows cast by the sun in an environment with no atmosphere.

  5. Clarence Tennis says:

    I don’t know why, but I have the hardest time seeing proper relief when the image is illuminated from “above.” The images with “southern” light are easier for me to see proper relief. It’s so common for me to see relief inversion I’ve just accepted it and remember the what is up is down.

  6. Carrie Snider says:

    Nice knowing I am not alone geeking out on rocks. Seeking a career that utilizes my skills ,develops talent with regard to my above average
    iQ score Visual Pattern Recognition . Skeptic at heart, test was too easy. Rock on.

Leave a Reply

Keep comments relevant. Inappropriate or offensive comments may be edited and/or deleted. Avoid adding Web site urls.